No announcement yet.

How long would a sword last *really*?

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • How long would a sword last *really*?

    I mean in terms of carrying the same sword through the centuries, getting into bunches of sword fights. How long would, say, an actual katana hold up?

    I feel like even the finest crafted katanas only last for a couple of swordfights in Japan's history before they either break or are dangerously damaged, no?
    Highlander: Dark Places

  • #2
    There are actual katana hundreds of years old. How many times they were used in combat? I have no clue. Edge to edge strikes would yield tremendous pressures and I have to believe they would do significant damage. Perhaps they rotated the blade when blocking or parrying to be less damaging to such a valuable weapon. I can't imagine they disposed of blades as if they were razor blades.

    Connor's may have had healing properties. Brenda took a chunk half the size of a fingernail out of that concrete column, but there was no apparent damage.


    • #3
      I's a kind of magic! I don't think Ramirez Masamune katana would have lasted from 596 BC to Connor's fight against the Kurgan, he must have repaired it countless of times as he did in Highlander III!


      • #4
        Just keeping it sharp would destroy it. I have one of my grandmother's knives that's about half it's original width, and that's less than a century.


        • #5
          A good sword probably lasts a couple of decades with active use. They're probably prone to Theseus's paradox.

          May flights of Demons guide you to your final rest...


          • dubiousbystander
            dubiousbystander commented
            Editing a comment
            The swords are semi-Immortal by proximity and regenerate!

          • Nicholas Ward
            Nicholas Ward commented
            Editing a comment
            Self-healing swords!

        • #6
          I would probaably get a new on once there were too many nicks in the blade.


          • #7
            Originally posted by Saber Dog View Post
            Brenda took a chunk half the size of a fingernail out of that concrete column, but there was no apparent damage.
            That always bugged me. Like, damn... that came off the sword?
            Highlander: Dark Places


            • Freebooter
              Freebooter commented
              Editing a comment
              Me too. If a chunk that big broke off my blade I would get a new sword, thinking that big chip weakened my blade where it mighty break or something

          • #8
            That is a really good question ... =O
            If you take care carefully of your sword, it could serve you well your lifetime ... and beyond
            Last edited by Kladdagh; 09-30-2018, 09:21 AM.
            La Peur Tue l'Esprit ...


            • #9
              I've seen a cut down katana. It came to the US after WWII as a broken souvenir and the owner sharpened it and used it as a yard knife. I really wanted to take off the handle to see if it had kanji.
              “A sinner can always repent, but stupid is forever.”
              Billy Sunday