Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How long would a sword last *really*?

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Andrew NDB
    started a topic How long would a sword last *really*?

    How long would a sword last *really*?

    I mean in terms of carrying the same sword through the centuries, getting into bunches of sword fights. How long would, say, an actual katana hold up?

    I feel like even the finest crafted katanas only last for a couple of swordfights in Japan's history before they either break or are dangerously damaged, no?

  • Darth Reaper
    commented on 's reply
    It very well could be.

  • Perfect Warrior
    replied
    So the 'this is my grandfather's axe' thing. (I've replaced the handle five times and the head once, but this is my grandfather's axe.)

    Leave a comment:


  • Darth Reaper
    replied
    It's probably also worth it to consider what materials the swords are made with. Modern steel might last longer than, say, iron or bronze.

    I would wager that the practical answer to this question is that Immortals replace parts of their swords from time to time when they're damaged, or simply get new swords or have new versions of their old ones made. I'll bet that the sword The Kurgan uses in 1985 isn't the same sword that he used when he first met Connor in Scotland.

    But, I do kind of like the idea that over time an Immortal's sword could be imbued with some of its owner's Quickening, making it stronger and resistant to the ravages of time. Whether this would be done intentionally, is the result of prolonged close proximity to the Immortal, or could even be some kind of psychological effect may depend on the Immortal.

    Leave a comment:


  • Andrew NDB
    replied
    Originally posted by Colleengael View Post
    Even Adrian taught us during the sword experience to block with the side of the blade instead of using the edge. He said that a swordsman must keep his wrists strong and flexible because you want to protect the cutting edge of your blade. He also reminded everyone not to touch the metal blades with your fingers because the oil from your body also contains acids which can damage your blade if you don't clean it regularly and properly. Other martial arts instructors that I have had told me the same thing.
    It's true. I've handled swords, put them back in their scabbards to sit in the shadows for years... then pulled them out and can see my fingerprints rusted into the metal of the blade. Whoops!

    Leave a comment:


  • Colleengael
    replied
    Even Adrian taught us during the sword experience to block with the side of the blade instead of using the edge. He said that a swordsman must keep his wrists strong and flexible because you want to protect the cutting edge of your blade. He also reminded everyone not to touch the metal blades with your fingers because the oil from your body also contains acids which can damage your blade if you don't clean it regularly and properly. Other martial arts instructors that I have had told me the same thing.

    Leave a comment:


  • klimbo123
    replied
    There are real katana several years of age. How often they were utilized in battle? I do not understand. Edge to edge strikes would yield enormous weights and I need to trust they would do noteworthy harm. Maybe they turned the edge when blocking Lucky Patcher 9Apps VidMate or repelling to be less harming to such an important weapon. I can't envision they discarded cutting edges as though they were extremely sharp edges
    Last edited by klimbo123; 02-18-2019, 11:27 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Coolwater
    replied
    I've seen a cut down katana. It came to the US after WWII as a broken souvenir and the owner sharpened it and used it as a yard knife. I really wanted to take off the handle to see if it had kanji.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nicholas Ward
    commented on 's reply
    Self-healing swords!

  • dubiousbystander
    commented on 's reply
    The swords are semi-Immortal by proximity and regenerate!

  • Kladdagh
    replied
    That is a really good question ... =O
    If you take care carefully of your sword, it could serve you well your lifetime ... and beyond
    Last edited by Kladdagh; 09-30-2018, 09:21 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Freebooter
    commented on 's reply
    Me too. If a chunk that big broke off my blade I would get a new sword, thinking that big chip weakened my blade where it mighty break or something

  • Andrew NDB
    replied
    Originally posted by Saber Dog View Post
    Brenda took a chunk half the size of a fingernail out of that concrete column, but there was no apparent damage.
    That always bugged me. Like, damn... that came off the sword?

    Leave a comment:


  • Freebooter
    replied
    I would probaably get a new on once there were too many nicks in the blade.

    Leave a comment:


  • Nicholas Ward
    replied
    A good sword probably lasts a couple of decades with active use. They're probably prone to Theseus's paradox.

    Leave a comment:


  • Perfect Warrior
    replied
    Just keeping it sharp would destroy it. I have one of my grandmother's knives that's about half it's original width, and that's less than a century.

    Leave a comment:


  • Gardner
    replied
    I's a kind of magic! I don't think Ramirez Masamune katana would have lasted from 596 BC to Connor's fight against the Kurgan, he must have repaired it countless of times as he did in Highlander III!

    Leave a comment:


  • Saber Dog
    replied
    There are actual katana hundreds of years old. How many times they were used in combat? I have no clue. Edge to edge strikes would yield tremendous pressures and I have to believe they would do significant damage. Perhaps they rotated the blade when blocking or parrying to be less damaging to such a valuable weapon. I can't imagine they disposed of blades as if they were razor blades.

    Connor's may have had healing properties. Brenda took a chunk half the size of a fingernail out of that concrete column, but there was no apparent damage.

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X