Fight of the Day shall Return!

[Nicholas Ward]

ROUND 5

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Ceirdwyn

2.
Caspian vs. Kalas

3.
Grayson vs. Haresh Clay

4.
Kassim vs. Duncan MacLeod

1. Brian Cullen would easily beat a barbarian.

2. Caspian was old, mad and didn't fight much because he was held in an asylum. He wasn't as good as the other horsemen. I'm sure Kalas would best him.

3. This is a great fight. But unlike the others I think Grayson is the one winning in the end. He is much more levelheaded.

4. Other than the Kurgan, there aren't any left that could beat Duncan MacLeod. But Kassim is the only one where MacLeod had to resort to other means to win. I'll give this to Kassim, so that the option exist to get Duncan out.

[JedimstrCR]

Here we go:

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Ceirdwyn

Not a lot of visual evidence on either, but Cullen has the better rep.

2.
Caspian vs. Kalas

Kalas was a fine duelist, but he didn't trust his skill. Hence the cheating. Caspian was a murdering machine who wouldn't be intimidated in a straight up fight.

3.
Grayson vs. Haresh Clay

This would be a terrific matchup. Clay was the type of guy Grayson would love to go after. I think that this time he would be biting off more than he can chew.

4.
Kassim vs. Duncan MacLeod

This would go much the same way as their TV fight, but prime Mac would be a bit better.

[Aragorn]

ROUND 5

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Ceirdwyn

Brian Cullen. I think he was a prodigy when it comes to sword fighting. Being the best sword fighter on a continent where it was extremely trendy to be a duelist says you were pretty darn amazing.
VOTE: Brian Cullen

2.
Caspian vs. Kalas

So both are great fighters and I think this would be awesome. I'm going with Caspian based off the fact that he's been murdering people a whole lot longer and doesn't seem to need to cheat (IE get rusty immortals after they've been on Holy Ground for a bit, or running them over with cars, or trying to get them to give up their heads without a fight, etc.).
VOTE: Caspian

3.
Grayson vs. Haresh Clay

Clay was a very experience duelist and clearly enjoyed taking on the best. Taking out Graham Ashe like he was trash tells me he'd probably be able to deal with Grayson.
VOTE: Haresh Clay

4.
Kassim vs. Duncan MacLeod

Again, no unusual circumstances Duncan won cleanly. I know he got lucky stumbling onto that knife on the table and the fight COULD go another way, but he won and I don't think it was total luck he won. If they fight 100 times, Duncan wins more than he loses.
VOTE: Duncan

[Aragorn]

ROUND 5

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Ceirdwyn

2.
Caspian vs. Kalas

3.
Grayson vs. Haresh Clay

4.
Kassim vs. Duncan MacLeod

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

Kyra d. Michael Kent
Kurgan d. Jacob Kell
Xavier St. Cloud d. Steven Keane
Rebecca Horne d. Slan Quince

[Mr.Slash]

ROUND 4

1.
Kyra - Kent will have a good showing. Not good enough.

2.
The Kurgan - Yeah Kell, let's see some of your mind games here. Twit.

3.
Xavier St. Cloud

4.
Rebecca Horne - Slan was lame.

[Nicholas Ward]

ROUND 4

1.
Michael Kent vs. Kyra

2.
Jacob Kell vs. The Kurgan

3.
Steven Keane vs. Xavier St. Cloud

4.
Slan Quince vs. Rebecca Horne

1. Michael Kent has the best training money can buy. Kyra has experience. This will be a fun fight but Kyra should win this. Winner: Kyra

2. Kurgan and Kell match up as a draw in my book. The Kurgan is stronger but Kell is the better swordsman. I'd give it to Kell, just barely. Winner: Jacob Kell

3. Yeah, not really a contest here. Xavier St. Cloud takes out Keane easy. Winner: Xavier St. Cloud

4. Unless Rebecca gets surprised by the hidden weapon of Slan Quince, she'll take this fight. Winner: Rebecca Horne

[JedimstrCR]

I'm on vacation right now, so copy and paste Aragorn's votes LOL.

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Michael Kent vs. Kyra

Kyra is super old and has been a fighter and active her whole career, as far as we know. Kent's a decent sword fighter but I think Kyra's probably a bit better.
VOTE: Kyra

2.
Jacob Kell vs. The Kurgan

This is a great opportunity to get rid of Kell.
VOTE: Kurgan

3.
Steven Keane vs. Xavier St. Cloud

Duncan squashed Keane. Wasn't close. Duncan v Xavier was super close multiple times. I also think Xavier's style matches up exceptionally well against Keane.
VOTE: Xavier

4.
Slan Quince vs. Rebecca Horne

Slan's the type of good Rebecca would out smart and cut down. Little doubt she'd beat him.
VOTE: Rebecca

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Michael Kent vs. Kyra

2.
Jacob Kell vs. The Kurgan

3.
Steven Keane vs. Xavier St. Cloud

4.
Slan Quince vs. Rebecca Horne

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

Consone d. Katharine
Kronos d. Luther
Silas d. Reno
Zai Jie d. Walter Graham

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Katharine vs. Otavio Consone

I think Katherine would put up a good fight but I agree Consone would skewer her.
VOTE: Consone

2.
Luther vs. Kronos

Not close, Kronos wins quickly.
VOTE: Kronos

3.
Silas vs. Reno

Silas would have fun with Reno.
VOTE: Silas

4.
Walter Graham vs. Zai Jie

I agree this would be a respectable fight but I agree that I think Zai would win a sporting fight.
VOTE: Zai Jie

[dubiousbystander]

ROUND 4

1. Katherine vs. Otavio Consone
Yeah, Consone is better. Poor thing.

2. Luther vs. Kronos
Luther thinks he needs the Methuselah Stone. Nothing short of that would save him from Kronos.

3. Silas vs. Reno
Silas all the way! Reno's never fought an Immortal in his life.

4. Walter Graham vs. Zai Jie
Definitely Zai.

[Nicholas Ward]

ROUND 4

1.
Katharine vs. Otavio Consone

2.
Luther vs. Kronos

3.
Silas vs. Reno

4.
Walter Graham vs. Zai Jie

1.
Katharine is very good but has absolutely nothing on Consone. Consone will take her head. Winner: Otavio Consone

2.
And that'll be the swift end of Luther as well. Winner: Kronos

3.
How did Reno get into such predicament? His lucky streak gets axed. Winner: Silas

4.
This is an interesting fight. They're both very good but the showmanship of Walter will be his downfall. Zai Jie will cut down Walter Grahams theatrics. Winner: Zai Jie

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Katharine vs. Otavio Consone

2.
Luther vs. Kronos

3.
Silas vs. Reno

4.
Walter Graham vs. Zai Jie

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

Haresh Clay d. Ernst Daimler
Duncan MacLeod d. Everett Bellian
Ceirdwyn d. Axel Whittaker
Kalas d. Caleb Cole

[dubiousbystander]

ROUND 4

1.
Haresh Clay vs. Ernst Daimler
CLAY all the way! Barring accident.

2.
Duncan MacLeod vs. Everett Bellian
As has been said, Duncan.

3.
Axel Whittaker vs. Ceirdwyn
Snort. Ceirdwyn. Axel is just not good enough.

4.
Caleb Cole vs. Kalas
I'm torn, because they're both slime. However, it would more likely go to Kalas from what little we saw of Caleb. Could we apply the astronaut vs cavemen?

[JedimstrCR]

1.
Haresh Clay vs. Ernst Daimler

Daimler was a tough fighter but Clay was much more disciplined (assuming his boyfriend didn't just die before this match lol).

2.
Duncan MacLeod vs. Everett Bellian

Prime Mac takes out the colonel with much more ease than his less-experienced self.

3.
Axel Whittaker vs. Ceirdwyn

Visually, Axel was awesome. But there was a reason he used those women...those insecurities would surface tenfold against a seasoned female vet like Ceirdwyn, and she'd make him pay.

4.
Caleb Cole vs. Kalas

Kalas wins a bloody, nasty fight.

[Nicholas Ward]

ROUND 4

1.
Haresh Clay vs. Ernst Daimler

2.
Duncan MacLeod vs. Everett Bellian

3.
Axel Whittaker vs. Ceirdwyn

4.
Caleb Cole vs. Kalas

1. Ernst Daimler was pretty good, he'll put up a great fight but will lose to Clay. Winner: Haresh Clay
2. We've seen this fight. Duncan takes it. Winner: Duncan MacLeod
3. Axel Whittakers view of women will definitely improve after he takes Ceirdwyn down. Winner: Axel Whittaker
4. I'm not sure Kalas would be able to take out Caleb Cole, He'll cringe and drop his guard every time he hears Cole spout out that accent. Winner: Caleb Cole

[Mr.Slash]

ROUND 4

1.
Haresh Clay - Fairly good, but Clay was better. Clay would probably get a bit of enjoyment out of this due to Daimler's beliefs.

2.
Duncan MacLeod - We saw how that one turned out in season 1. Duncan just kept getting better.

3.
Ceirdwyn - With no newbies to use here, Axel won't be able to take it.

4.
Kalas - I pretty much agree with what Aragorn said. Caleb will give him fits, but Kalas will take it.

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Haresh Clay vs. Ernst Daimler

I honestly think Clay would trash Daimler. Not even close.
VOTE: Clay

2.
Duncan MacLeod vs. Everett Bellian

Duncan beat him in season 1, it wouldn't be as close with season 6 Duncan.
VOTE: Duncan

3.
Axel Whittaker vs. Ceirdwyn

Hmmm, this is REALLY tough. This fight would be pretty awesome. Hmmmmmmmmm. Gut tells me Ceirdwyn would win but I haven't really seen her fight and Axel was soooooooo good. I'll give it to him in a nail biter even though my gut is telling me this is wrong.
VOTE: Axel Whittaker

4.
Caleb Cole vs. Kalas

I actually think Caleb would give Kalas trouble. I don't think this is a good match up for him. Still, I think more often than not Kalas would win. But if they fought 10 times, I think Caleb would take a few of them.
VOTE: Kalas

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Haresh Clay vs. Ernst Daimler

2.
Duncan MacLeod vs. Everett Bellian

3.
Axel Whittaker vs. Ceirdwyn

4.
Caleb Cole vs. Kalas

[Aragorn]

ROUND 4

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Darius

I think this would be a pretty awesome match but agree Cullen would likely win.
VOTE: Cullen

2.
Claude Deveraux vs. Caspian

I think Caspian would trash this guy.
VOTE: Caspian

3.
Grayson vs. Iman Fasil

Agree this is a pretty good fight. Also agree Grayson would win.
VOTE: Grayson

4.
Graham Ashe vs. Kassim

Again, agree with everyone. Ashe should win on paper but I think Kassim would surprise him.
VOTE: Kassim

[JedimstrCR]

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Darius

Prime Darius was probably no slouch, but his technique would be woefully outdated. Cullen should take this handily.

2.
Claude Deveraux vs. Caspian

If Deveraux had that much trouble with Felice, he'll be skewered by Caspian.

3.
Grayson vs. Iman Fasil

Each of these guys gave a MacLeod an epic fight. Grayson came closer to actually winning, so he gets by.

4.
Graham Ashe vs. Kassim

Ashe was such a disappointment after the buildup and Ramirez-name dropping. Kassim gave near-prime Duncan a helluva match. Easy choice for me.

[Nicholas Ward]

ROUND 4

1.
Brian Cullen vs. Darius

2.
Claude Deveraux vs. Caspian

3.
Grayson vs. Iman Fasil

4.
Graham Ashe vs. Kassim

1.
Brian Cullen will take this fairly easy.

2.
This will actually be a fight. But Caspian is slightly better.

3.
A formal challenge between 2 businessmen. It'll take everything Iman Fasil has and it still won't be enough.
Grayson will take this eventually.

4.
Going by the numbers, Graham Ashe should win this. But I'll vote for Kassim here.