Immortal Summer Slam!

[Nicholas Ward]

Michael Kent takes out the ferocious Annie Devlin!

Michael Kent
Attack		90
Defence		94
Speed		79
Agility		80
Strength		80
Power:		424
Average:		85
Arrogance	-1%	-4
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
	Total:	419

Next fight:

David Quinlan (Highlander: The Watcher) versus Bartholomew (Highlander: The Series)

David Quinlan				Bartholomew
Attack		50		Attack		78
Defence		50		Defence		87
Speed		50		Speed		78
Agility		50		Agility		75
Strength		50		Strength		85
Power:		250	VS.	Power:		403
Average:		50		Average:		81
Arrogance	-0%	0		Arrogance	-2%	-8
Adaptability	10%	25		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
Inside information: Negate opponents Defence & Adaptability				Shield bearer: Bartolomew's Defence cannot be lowered.
Total:		275		Evil	Total:	395

[Aragorn]

Michael Kent would beat her in less than 15 seconds.

[dubiousbystander]

You are great!

[Nicholas Ward]

True, I made up all stats. Still there is a system to it:
It largely follows the Tier list and the scale is from 0 to 500 with

0 = absolutely useless,
100 = decent,
200 = good,
300 = very good,
400 = exceptional,
500 = perfect.

With that in mind I set Amanda at 350 and The Kurgan at 440 and judged all immortals' visual performances as well as the watcher files. That way I got numbers relative to the other immortals of the Tier list starting from the top down. All immortals are at their best, which is why Richie is ranked higher than Mako even though Mako was better at the time they met, for example.
Some immortals have special skills to help them and I tried to incorporate them as faithfully as I could. But everything is up for debate and I do tinker with the numbers and special skills from time to time.

All these fights, votes and comments help me standardise the net gain from a victory over a better or weaker immortal opponent.

[dubiousbystander]

You have said you just assign numbers. I think, as written, Annie would have been better than this. Though her arrogance and adaptability would have lowered her score.

So I'm going with Annie.

[Ceridwen]

Kent, easily.

[Nicholas Ward]

The Messenger is not a pacifist anymore!

The Messenger
Attack		4
Defence		3
Speed		77
Agility		55
Strength		88
Power:		220
Average:		44
Arrogance	-10%	-22
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
	Total:	198

Next fight:

Annie Devlin versus Michael Kent

Annie Devlin				Michael Kent
Attack		26		Attack		82
Defence		24		Defence		85
Speed		24		Speed		72
Agility		24		Agility		73
Strength		27		Strength		73
Power:		125	VS.	Power:		385
Average:		25		Average:		77
Arrogance	0%	0		Arrogance	-1%	-4
Adaptability	0%	0		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
Neutral	Total:	125		Neutral	Total:	381

[Aragorn]

Messy's always been a tough one to judge. He's hinted at a darker past, and even his present is dubious as to whether he can really be trusted to not take your head when you're not expecting it. Wells just seems like an average dude who fights only when provoked. If forced to fight, Messenger wins, because Ron Perlman. IE What he said.

[JedimstrCR]

Messy's always been a tough one to judge. He's hinted at a darker past, and even his present is dubious as to whether he can really be trusted to not take your head when you're not expecting it. Wells just seems like an average dude who fights only when provoked. If forced to fight, Messenger wins, because Ron Perlman.

[dubiousbystander]

Tough call, because character might be a factor here. For one thing, Faux-Methos, unless a liar, is not going to take Alan's head. Alan, a man who tried his best to care for Mikey, is also not going to go for the Messenger's head. Yes, the Messenger will win. Both will walk away, probably discussing ways to keep Mikey safe.

[Nicholas Ward]

Coltec swiftly executes Crowley!

Jim Coltec
Attack		80
Defence		80
Speed		88
Agility		85
Strength		77
Power:		410
Average:		82
Arrogance	-1%	-4
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
Hyoka: Add the difference between opponents power and total to Jim Coltecs power.
	Total:	406

Next fight:

Alan Wells versus The Messenger

Alan Wells				The Messenger
Attack		18		Attack		0
Defence		15		Defence		0
Speed		16		Speed		70
Agility		16		Agility		50
Strength		26		Strength		80
Power:		91	VS.	Power:		200
Average:		18		Average:		40
Arrogance	0%	0		Arrogance	-10%	-20
Adaptability	0%	0		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
				Pacifism: Negate Attack & Defence. If The Messengers total is higher after applying special skills, the fight ends in a draw.
Good	Total:	91		Good	Total:	180

[dubiousbystander]

Coltec takes him! Muahah

[JedimstrCR]

Either good or bad Coltec would take Crowley, no question.

[Ceridwen]

Pretty clear that Coltec has this one in the bag, and that's good guy Coltec, too.

[Nicholas Ward]

Milius kills Talbott!

Kagan Milius
Attack		56
Defence		62
Speed		62
Agility		61
Strength		66
Power:		306
Average:		61
Arrogance	-1%	-3
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
Psychological Warfare: Lower opponents power by 15.
	Total:	303

Next Fight:

Jim Coltec versus Howard Crowley

Jim Coltec				Howard Crowley
Attack		73		Attack		44
Defence		73		Defence		38
Speed		80		Speed		40
Agility		77		Agility		37
Strength		70		Strength		60
Power:		373	VS.	Power:		219
Average:		75		Average:		44
Arrogance	-3%	-11		Arrogance	-1%	-2
Adaptability	0%	0		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
Hyoka: Add the difference between opponents power and total to Jim Coltecs power.
Good	Total:	362		Evil	Total:	217

[JedimstrCR]

By the numbers, Milius.

[Aragorn]

Kagan Milius this guy wins, I guess.

[Nicholas Ward]

Geary kills Basarab!

Wilson Geary
Attack		66
Defence		64
Speed		70
Agility		70
Strength		70
Power:		341
Average:		68
Arrogance	-2%	-7
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
	Total:	334

Next fight:

Kagan Milius (Highlander: The Watcher) versus Jason Talbot (Highlander: The Series)

Kagan Milius				Jason Talbot
Attack		51		Attack		16
Defence		56		Defence		16
Speed		56		Speed		16
Agility		55		Agility		16
Strength		60		Strength		16
Power:		278	VS.	Power:		80
Average:		56		Average:		16
Arrogance	-1%	-3		Arrogance	-1%	-1
Adaptability	0%	0		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
Psychological Warfare: Lower opponents power by 15.
Total:		275		Good	Total:	79

[dubiousbystander]

I have a nagging suspicion this was one of those where the message was "Do you want to restore a lost post?" I don't remember it. Fix fix fix!

[Nicholas Ward]

Lol, I think you're commenting on the wrong post.

[dubiousbystander]

Oh yes. Corda is out. Liam O'Rourke takes his head.

<-- oops.


Wilson Geary seems likely to take out Basarab IV Tepelus cel Tânär, my that's a long name!

[Aragorn]

I'll do what Ceridwen says and go with the guy from the Raven. It has been too long, I don't remember him.

[Ceridwen]

No idea,never having seen the fan film, judging from the numbers it'll be Geary.

[Nicholas Ward]

An easy kill and addition to Caspians power

Caspian
Attack		91
Defence		91
Speed		91
Agility		90
Strength		88
Power:		452
Average:		90
Arrogance	-3%	-14
Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:
Madness: Caspian's power can not be altered.
	Total:	439

Next fight:

Wilson Geary (Highlander: The Raven) versus Basarab IV Tepelus cel Tânär (Highlander: Dark Places)

Wilson Geary				Basarab
Attack		60		Attack		43
Defence		58		Defence		44
Speed		64		Speed		36
Agility		64		Agility		35
Strength		64		Strength		41
Power:		310	VS.	Power:		199
Average:		62		Average:		40
Arrogance	2%	-6		Arrogance	0%	0
Adaptability	0%	0		Adaptability	0%	0
Special skill:				Special skill:
Total:		304		Total:		199

[Ceridwen]

Caspian without question.